“The Future of Text” hits the streets

Congratulations to Frode Heglund, convenor for 9 years of the widely respected Future of Text Symposium, who has just edited and published The Future of Text book! The book is “a letter to the distant future”, in which an astonishingly diverse group of people share perspectives on where humanity has got to with the symbol systems we use to codify and share ideas — “Text” — and where we might be going. I was honoured to be invited to contribute to this: The Future of Text in Three Moves.

From the book’s introduction:

“I have invited some truly phenomenal people to contribute to this work, and against all odds, they said yes. There are eminent representatives from the worlds of art, typography, science, software development, academia and more. Text writes our history, and text guides our future, but text itself is not often reflected on, let alone written about.”

You can replay videos from the launch event, which was introduced by no less than Vint Cerf who has supported this work from its early days:

Well it’s been a hell of a year, so here’s a book to settle down with over Christmas and New Year, accompanied by your favourite brew, to dip into at random and make some space for reflection. Give it to all your friends and family! The pieces are short (some only a page), and a mind-stretching joy to browse.

I’m old enough to still love the weighty-tome gravitas of the printed volume in the above photo, but of course, most of us will read this digitally. It’s freely available as PDF | EPUB, and the PDF takes on greater interactive qualities when viewed in Frode’s Reader hypertext tool. Here’s his demo of this and the other tools he’s been inventing…

Alert to the challenge of digital preservation (“we’re writing in sand” as Frode memorably states about digital texts) — they’re working on a physical edition with the entire text micro-engraved into plastic and metal for longevity.

Frode kindly invited me to contribute a chapter, which gave me a much appreciated pause for thought on the 30 years I’ve spent using hypertext to create interactive visualisations of dialogue and arguments, and in the last decade or so, learning from my NLP and machine learning colleagues. So, here’s my letter to the future: The Future of Text in Three Moves.

Many congratulations also to Niko Grupen, whose piece From Author to Editor: Our Place Alongside the New Life Cycle of Text (p.148) scooped first prize in the Student Competition! His punishment is to read a signed Visualizing Argumentation e-book cover-to-cover over Christmas 😉

Doug Engelbart (RIP) is the fire driving both Frode and me (his influence on my career) — so for old time’s sake, here’s when Doug and Frode Heglund visited me in 2004 🙂

2 tools to help PhD students make their thinking visible

In this post, I share two ways to map your thinking, at different scales (rather like geographical maps)…

CQOCE Diagrams (or “Thesis Maps”)

One of the challenges that most/all PhD students have is to make their thinking visible — to themselves, to their supervisors, and to other researchers. There are so many potential ideas to weave into a narrative, and often different narrative pathways.

In our Learning Analytics PhD Program, we’ve been using the unpronounceable but very useful CQOCE diagram described by Luis Prieto in his Happy PhD blog. I encourage you to learn more about this:

“the diagram is commonly used in the introduction section of a dissertation, and it is meant to introduce, in graphical form, some of its main elements: the research Context, main research Question, Objectives, Contributions of your thesis and their Evaluation. However, many of us have also used it way before starting to write the dissertation book itself, as a “guiding star” when discussing with others and planning the thesis work.”

We have also been using it not just as a writing up device, but as a challenge right in the first year, to get doctoral researchers thinking about their thesis story. I tend to just call it the Thesis Map! As Luis comments, this goes through many revisions as the PhD takes its twists and turns. So in the end it serves two key purposes:

  1. As a mirror for the supervision team to reflect on how we’re doing — “Oh, the contributions I thought I was making don’t align with the Research Questions…” “What kind of evaluation will be needed next year to back up this claimed Contribution 2?…”
  2. As a navigational aid — a map — for the reader of the thesis, or indeed, for the audience if it’s used in a talk (“…in this talk I’ll be covering only this part of the map, but it shows you how this is a stage in a longer journey, in a  wider landscape…”)

Here are two recent Learning Analytics theses that use this, from Vanessa Echeverria and Carlos Prieto.

Echeverria, V. (2020). Designing Feedback for Collocated Teams using Multimodal Learning Analytics

Prieto-Alvarez, C.G. (2020), Engaging Stakeholders in the Learning Analytics Design Process

        

Note that sections of the map can then be introduced in each chapter, to remind the reader where we are on the journey.

Argument Maps

The Thesis Map provides a macro-structure for the thesis argument: once you’ve bashed your map into shape, then your high level claim to have evidenced contributions to advance knowledge that addresses important RQs just drops out naturally. But there will be many micro-level arguments in the thesis that are invisible at this scale.

Zooming in, we’re experimenting with Argument Maps, that make visible more detailed moves. Here’s my briefing during a PhD session which introduces some basics…

2 weeks later, a couple of researchers shared their maps for feedback, and both commented on how it helps clarify thinking. Thanks to Ben Hicks and Gloria Fernandez-Nieto for jumping in!

Ben used the freely accessible ArgDown website which uses a classic Argument Map notation, enriched with optional colour-coding from #tags:

Gloria used the free Compendium tool that my team developed at KMi Open University, using the IBIS notation (QuickStart Guide to install):

Note: Al Selvin inventor and power user of Compendium, used it to create multimedia maps of his thesis thinking and qualitative data analysis [screen demos], incorporating many kinds of documents (which can be dragged and dropped onto maps).

    

Far more info on Knowledge Cartography is available if this interests you.

I hope these help you make your own thinking more visible — to yourself, your supervisors, and the world  🙂