Election Debate: seeing Nick Clegg’s moves

Following last night’s real time mapping of the first TV election debate, here’s one thought from reviewing the maps over breakfast…

One of the noticeable moves that Nick Clegg made, which has been much commented on, was his ability to position himself as moving beyond the  traditional Labour-Tory face-off, seeking to open up new space by questioning major premises behind their policies.

We can see this move very clearly in several of the debate maps, in which he uses his contribution to critique both Brown and Cameron.


Another visual pattern to emerge is from the final debate on care for the elderly, which Clegg dominated. He shaped the whole discourse through his opening contribution, appealing for a cross-party solution to a challenge that’s bigger than any party. Brown and Cameron rally under this sentiment following the consensual tone (lots of green supports connections), with Clegg wrapping it up with the final word.

There is only so much that real time dialogue maps such as these can yield, since they are crafted under time pressure, but even as I was mapping it, I was very conscious of the move he was making, which is part of the point of such approaches: the medium draws attention to potentially significant phenomena as you model them.

5 Responses to “Election Debate: seeing Nick Clegg’s moves”

  1. Fantastic job Simon!
    It really shows how argument mapping can help make sense of a lengthy debate. Would you consider showing some or all of the maps at the OD2010 conference?

  2. This is very interesting and revealing, Simon. Have you thought about releasing it to the media? Much has been written about Clegg’s strong performance last night, but it’s all been pretty impressionistic. You do seem to be taking it on to another level here.

  3. Hi Ann

    Thanks. Yes, I’ll certainly be sharing some of this at the OD2010 workshop and panel. Further analysis planned, and about to move it into Cohere for open, asynchronous contributions.


  4. Stephen – thanks. So far this has been tweeted quite a bit, and blogged by a few Open U people and channels, and as we deepen the analysis we’ll probably spread the word more.



  5. Note that this pilot work has since developed into a new project to map the anticipated 2015 Election Debates: http://edv-project.net


Leave a Reply

You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>